Best Bagels in Port St. Lucie

Taste the Tradition, Savor the Flavor: Over 30 Years of Freshly Baked Excellence!

Welcome to Bagel Brothers, Where Tradition Lives!

We take pride in serving fresh, handcrafted bagels, sandwiches, wraps, and more. Our bagels are made the old-fashioned way— with only the finest ingredients. Whether you're stopping by for a quick breakfast or grabbing a hearty lunch, we’ve got you covered.

Bagels Done Right in Every Bite

Get a taste of New York with our legendary bagels! Hand-rolled, boiled, and baked to golden perfection, they’re crisp on the outside, soft and chewy on the inside—just the way a bagel should be. From classic plain to sesame, everything, and beyond, we’ve got a flavor to satisfy every craving. Whether you’re grabbing a quick breakfast, pairing it with your favorite schmear, or enjoying it as a snack, our bagels bring the perfect bite every time.

Start Your Day with Signature Flavors!

Looking for something heartier? Our menu features an array of breakfast classics, savory wraps, toast and paninis made fresh to order. From our signature egg and cheese bagels to chicken wraps bursting with flavor, there’s something for everyone. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing a quick bite on the go, our friendly team is here to ensure you leave satisfied

A Taste of New York’s Finest Bagels

Browse our mouthwatering selection of freshly made bagels, delicious spreads, and signature creations

Order From Our Website

Skip the middleman and enjoy the freshest bagels and deli delights straight from Bagel Brothers of New York! Ordering from our website is quick, easy, and ensures you get the best deals.

Order Now

Freshness Delivered: Nationwide Shipping in 2 Days

Craving our fresh bagels but can’t make it in? No problem! We offer 2-day nationwide shipping, so you can enjoy your favorites no matter where you are. Whether you're sending a gift to a loved one or treating yourself, we make it easy to get our handcrafted goodness delivered straight to your door. Experience the taste wherever you are—because great food knows no boundaries!

Order Now

Catering Made Easy

Planning an event or meeting? Let us take care of the food! Our catering menu features a variety of delicious options, from freshly baked bagels to hearty wraps and sandwiches—perfect for any occasion. Ordering is simple! Place your catering order online, and we’ll handle the rest. Whether it’s breakfast for a corporate event or a casual gathering, we’ve got you covered with fast, friendly service and food everyone will love.

Order Catering Now

What our customers are saying

Check out our most recent reviews!

These guys are the absolute best! The staff is awesome. And the owner is a really cool dude. They have the best bagels Iv had since I left Jersey. Easily the best place to get breakfast in Tradition, and one of the best -not so hidden gems- in PSL.

Joe R.

You can have regular decaf decaf and they did have a wide variety selection of different flavor additives if you wanted to add creamers and what not.

Monica P.

Thank you Kevin for the great suggestion this morning for Breakfast! The Avocado, Egg Whites, and Bagel hit the spot. Good Service, good food, and good vibes.